top of page
Search
  • Seven

The Ultimate Guide to Herding Toys: How to Choose the Best Toys for Your Working Dog

Updated: May 31

Herding toys are a type of dog toy that is designed to mimic the movements and behaviors of prey animals so that herding behavior appears. They are often used in training and playtime for dogs who have an natural instinct to herd or chase after small animals. These toys can also provide mental stimulation and physical exercise for dogs, helping to keep them entertained and healthy.


Two border collie tongue out sitting next to a blue herding ball in a grassy backyard
Herding toys

In this document, we will explore the different types of herding dog toys available, their benefits and drawbacks, and how to choose the right one for your herding dogs.

Herding toys, such as balls or motion-activated toys, are specifically designed to simulate the movement and behavior of small animals that dogs might naturally herd, such as sheep or cattle. These toys engage the dog's innate herding instincts and provide them with healthy physical and mental exercise. Examples of herding breed of dogs with strong herding instincts include the Border Collie, Australian Shepherd, Australian Cattle dogs, German Shepherds, Sheltie (Shetland Sheepdog), Corgi (both Pembroke and Cardigan Welsh), Belgian Malinois, Rough Collie, Old English Sheepdog, Australian Cattle Dog, and the Bearded Collie. These herding dogs, among other dogs, can particularly benefit from herding toys as part of their regular play and training regimen.





The Psychology Behind Herding Toys


A shepherd dog sittin on top of a blue herding ball on grassland
Herding Toys

Dogs have been bred for centuries to perform specific tasks, such as hunting, guarding, or herding. This is why working dogs often exhibit certain natural instincts and behaviors that are linked to their ancestral activities. For instance, herding dog breeds have a natural urge to chase and control the movement of other animals.

Herding dog toys tap into this natural instinct by providing a moving target for dogs to chase and control. This can be mentally satisfying for them as it gives them a sense of purpose and fulfillment.

Herding dog toys engage a dog's natural instincts to hunt, chase, and control movement. These behaviors can also help develop their problem-solving skills as they strategize ways to catch and control the toy.

Moreover, these toys can also provide a sense of companionship for dogs who may be left alone for long periods by dog owners. The moving target can simulate the presence of another animal, keeping them company and providing stimulation.

Just like humans, dogs, especially working breeds like border collies or Australian

A Border Collie herding a red herding ball on a grassland.
Herding Toys

shepherds, need both mental and physical exercise to maintain a healthy mind and body. Incorporating playtime with herding dog toys in their daily routine can help fulfill these needs, preventing boredom and destructive behaviors; and provides a healthy outlet for the enerrgy of the dogs.

Furthermore, regular playtime can also strengthen the bond between a dog and their owner. By engaging in activities together, owners can build trust and communication with their dogs.

When choosing a herding toy for your dog, it's important to consider their size, age, and breed. Smaller dogs may prefer smaller toys that are easier to control, while larger dogs may need more durable and challenging toys. Working breeds like Australian shepherds, and German shepherds are big and strong when playing, their excess energy and high speed might be challenging for toy's durability.


A shepherd dog herding a red herding ball near the woven mesh
Herding Toys

It's also important to choose a toy made with safe and non-toxic materials. Some herding dog toys are designed to be indestructible, made up of hard plastic, but it's still important to supervise playtime and replace any damaged or worn-out toys.

In addition, it's helpful to rotate between different herding dog toys to keep your dog mentally stimulated and prevent boredom.


Types of Herding Toys


There are various types of herding dog toys available, each with their own unique features and benefits. Some of the best toys on the market include:


  • Flirt poles: These long sticks with a toy attached to the end allow for interactive play between owner and dog, simulating chasing and capturing prey. Most dogs enjoy playing with a flirt pole.

  • Frisbees and flying discs: A great exercise for most dogs who love to run and jump, these toys can be tossed for your dog to catch and return to you. Frisbees are usually made of hard plastic, so be careful for breaks and cracks.

  • Ball launchers: These devices are great for dogs who love to fetch. They allow the owner to throw a rubber ball at longer distances with minimal effort. It can be used for many dogs for training purposes. Any dog with a high prey drive like a German shepherd love chasing the balls.

  • Tug toys: Made with durable materials, tug toys are perfect for playing tug-of-

A little brown dog holding a blue herding ball in a grassland
Herding Toys

war with your dog, providing both physical and mental stimulation.

  • Puzzle toys: These interactive dog toys require your dog to solve a puzzle in order to receive a treat, providing mental exercise and satisfying their natural instincts to work for food. Most dogs love to get treat.

  • Herding balls: These large, bouncy balls are great for herding breeds as they mimic the movements of livestock and can provide a fun and challenging game of fetch. One of the best herding ball on the market is the Collieball. This unique toy has three different sizes (18, 22 and 30 inch wide) for wide variety of working dogs from small dogs like corgi, or big one like German shepherd. Colliebal is the one of the most affordable option for your pup who love chasing balls. It is made up of rubber balls which is better than soccer balls which may harm paws and nose of your pup while chasing after.


Benefits of Herding Toys



Herding dog toys not only provide mental stimulation for your dog, but they also offer physical exercise and contribute to their overall health. Playing with herding toys can help strengthen muscles, improve coordination and balance, and promote cardiovascular health. Regular playtime with these toys can also help prevent obesity and other weight-related issues in dogs.


Herding breeds are known for their intelligence and instincts to herd, and herding toys provide an outlet for these behaviors. This can help prevent boredom and destructive behavior in these breeds, as they have a fun and constructive way to use their energy. Additionally, solving puzzles with puzzle toys can boost a dog's confidence and provide mental stimulation, leading to a happier and healthier pet.

Playing with toys together can strengthen the bond between you and your dog, as it promotes positive interactions and creates happy memories. This can also help in training and building trust with your furry friend. Additionally, playing with herding toys can also improve your dog's socialization skills, as it exposes them to different textures, sounds, and movements. This is especially beneficial for young puppies who are still learning about their surroundings.


A Kelpie herding blue herding ball in the grass backyard.
Herding Toys

Herding toys come in various sizes and designs, making them easily accessible and convenient for pet owners. They can be used both indoors and outdoors, allowing for playtime in any weather condition. Some herding toys also have interactive features such as treat dispensers or hidden compartments, making them versatile and engaging for all types of dogs. This makes it easier for pet owners to provide mental and physical stimulation for their pets without having to invest a lot of time or effort.









How to Choose the Best Herding Toy

When choosing a herding toy for your dog, there are a few factors to consider:


A German shepherd rests near the red herding ball on the floor of a kitchen
Herding Toys

  1. Size and Breed Suitability - Make sure the toy is appropriate for your dog's size and breed. Smaller breeds may have difficulty with larger toys, while bigger breeds may need more durable options.

  2. Material and Durability - Look for toys made of high-quality materials that can withstand your dog's bite force and rough play. Avoid toys with small or easily detachable parts that could pose a choking hazard.

  3. Interactive Features - Consider if the toy has any interactive features such as treat dispensers or puzzles, which can add an extra level of mental stimulation for your dog.

  4. Safety - Always prioritize safety when choosing a herding toy for your dog. Avoid toys with sharp edges or toxic materials.

  5. Cost and Value - While it's important to invest in a good quality herding toy, also consider the cost and value of the toy. Some may be more expensive but offer longer durability, while others may have a lower price point but still provide enough entertainment for your pet.

Final Thoughts



An Australian shepherd sitting next to the blue herding ball in the house.
Herding Toys

When it comes to choosing a herding toy for your dog, it's important to consider their individual needs and preferences. Whether they prefer interactive puzzles or simply love a good game of fetch, there is certainly a herding toy out there that will keep them entertained and happy. Remember to always prioritize safety and invest in a high-quality toy to ensure long-lasting fun for both you and your furry friend. So, the next time you're shopping for a herding toy, keep these considerations in mind to help you make the best choice for your beloved pet. Happy herding!

  • Overall, the most important thing is that your dog enjoys playing with the toy and that it promotes a healthy and safe playtime experience. With the right herding toy, you can keep your dog entertained, mentally stimulated, and physically active - all while strengthening the bond between you two. So don't be afraid to try out different options and see what works best for your furry companion.

  • Additionally, remember to regularly check your dog's toys for any signs of wear and tear, and replace them as needed to prevent any potential hazards. And always supervise your dog while playing with any toy to ensure their safety.

  • Finally, aside from physical toys, there are also other ways to engage in herding activities with your dog, such as using treats or training games. Be creative and have fun exploring different options to keep your dog excited and challenged! So, go ahead and start herding with your furry friend today - it's a rewarding and enjoyable experience for both of you. Happy herding!



"A tired dog is a happy dog" – so make sure to give your energetic herding dog the playtime they deserve with the perfect herding toy. Your pup will thank you with endless tail wags and happy barks. Have fun! Happy herding!

Now that you know the importance of herding toys for your dog, don't forget to also provide them with plenty of love, attention, and care. A well-rounded approach to a healthy pet includes not only physical exercise but also mental stimulation and emotional fulfillment. So make sure to show your furry companion how much they mean to you every day. After all, a happy dog means a happy owner! So keep playing and herding with your four-legged friend, and create unforgettable memories together.


A border collie herding the blue herding ball and  chasing after it
CollieBall - Original Herding Ball

Thank you for reading our guide on herding toys - we hope it helps enhance the bond between you and your beloved canine. Keep exploring and discovering new ways to keep your dog happy and healthy! Happy herding!


So, what are you waiting for? Start shopping for the perfect herding toy and have a blast playing with your furry companion.


Remember to choose toys that are suitable for your dog's size, breed, and personality, and always prioritize their safety. And don't forget the power of positive reinforcement and training in making playtime even more enjoyable for your dog. As they say, a well-trained dog is a happy dog! So whether you're herding for fun or have aspirations of competing in herding trials, make sure to incorporate the use of herding toys into your routine. Not only will it keep your dog physically and mentally stimulated, but it also strengthens the bond between you and your furry friend. Plus, who can resist those happy barks and wagging tails? So go out there and have a blast herding with your pup - it's an experience both of you will cherish forever! Happy herding!








3,566 views0 comments
bottom of page